Someone shared their AI position. Find out which one is yours.

Take the test

Critic · an AI position

Creators' Advocate

Human work deserves credit, consent and compensation.

CGJS01

You think AI is capable and are most concerned about its effect on people who make things: writers, artists, musicians and other workers whose output was used for training. You also care about what is lost when human craft is treated as raw material. You want consent, licensing and pay, and you are not asking for the technology to stop.

CCapability
CapableHighly capable, and improving.
GPace
GuardrailsContinue, with rules and testing.
JSConcerns
Jobs · SoulWork, workers and stolen work. What it does to being human.
01P(doom), 10 yrs
1% · Very lowUnlikely, but not zero.
“If it learned from our work, we should have a say and a share.”

Often disagrees with: Accelerationist

Recommended reading

Makes a similar case

Pushes back

See all the books. Links go to Bookshop.org.